[Home] [Groups] - Message: [Prev in Group] [Next in Group]
17086: Re: [MUD-Dev] Ebay bans character selling
[Full Header] [Plain Text]
From: Frank Crowell <frankc@maddog.com>
Newsgroups: nu.kanga.list.mud-dev
Date: Sun, 28 Jan 2001 13:22:20 -0800
References: [1]
Organization: Kanga.Nu
the_logos@www.achaea.com wrote:
> Ebay and Yahoo have banned the sale of virtual characters based on
> the fact that doing so violates the intellectual property rights of,
> say, Verant.
> While I certainly applaud this enforcement of Verant's rights, I
> wonder how long it will be until someone sets up an auction service
> specifically to cater to the buying and selling of virtual items and
> hosts it somewhere handily out of the reach of the US government.
It's not clear at all that any IP laws have been violated. There is
no transfer of items -- they are database entries. The only new
property that is "transferred" is the character itself -- created by
the player. Certainly the effort to create a character has more IP
value than a database entry.
I tried to contact Verant through their dev/null mail addresses on
this whole topic last spring. I felt that Sony/Verant were going
overboard and that there were more rational approaches to what they
preceived as a problem. Btw, at that time the issue was not IP; that
came later when Verant needed a way to get Ebay to take action.
I believe that Sony/Verant will do more harm in the long run by
driving this whole buying/selling business underground. At least Yahoo
and Ebay provided some protection to the buyer. And this in no way
solves the "account stealing" problem -- which was the real problem to
begin with.
frank
_______________________________________________
MUD-Dev mailing list
MUD-Dev@kanga.nu
https://www.kanga.nu/lists/listinfo/mud-dev